Greylisting and a backup MX, the start of a problem ?
Posted in: Spam
I’ve been reading up on the topic of greylisting and the techniques behind it and found out that it doesn’t quite work if you have a backup MX mailserver that does not have the same policy as your primary server. That is the situation I’m in and I think most of you as well.
If you have greylisting implemented on your primary server any email arriving will be checked against a stored list of previous encountered mailservers and mailadresses. If the combination is not known the sending mailserver will be asked to try again later. Most spammers will leave it at that. If you have received an x amount of mails from the same mailserver and mailaddress that combo will be whitelisted and always accepted directly.
The problem with backup MX servers is that they will be whitelisted and you need to accept all mail from that server because it will keep trying (as it is intended to do) ! If you don’t have control over the backup MX server and they don’t have a greylisting policy like you have or don’t do spamfiltering you have a backdoor that is wide open for spammers.
Read more on the subject in this whitepaper which describes it all in more detail.
Before we can use/implement greylisting we need to turn of our current backup MX and find someone else who will use the same policies and will want to be our backup MX, or just live without a backup mail server…
I would like to know your thoughts on this. What can I/we do to work this out ?